All stories

Affordability·Research·2 min read

Fixed incomes, rising bills

For households on a fixed income, a higher energy bill is not an inconvenience — it competes directly with groceries and prescriptions.

An older woman in glasses, a yellow shawl over her shoulders, reads bills at her living-room table.

A utility bill that goes up and stays up is a different thing for a household whose income cannot follow it. For seniors on Social Security and a pension, for people on disability, for anyone whose monthly number is set, a higher energy bill does not get absorbed. It gets taken from something else.

What the numbers say.

Electricity is 3.5 times more expensive than natural gas for the same household energy use. A household that keeps natural gas saves about $1,030 a year, and a home with gas could save $12,000 over 15 years compared with a new all-electric home. Residential electricity prices rose 74 percent in DC and 50 percent in Maryland from 2020 to 2025, and the regional grid is already short of the capacity it needs for 2028–29.

$1,030

What a household with natural gas saves in a year, compared with the all-electric alternative.

Those figures describe an average household. Low-income households already spend the largest share of their income on energy, and Black, Hispanic and low-income households carry more of that burden than the region as a whole. A cost increase of the same dollar amount is a larger share of a smaller budget.

The conversion no one on a fixed income can fund.

The gas bans reach new construction in both jurisdictions and major renovations in the District. A senior who owns an older home and needs a substantial renovation, a new roof and a kitchen after a leak, say, may find that the project has become an electrification project too. Converting heating, hot water, cooking and drying runs $22,500 to $40,000 before electrical work by AREA’s benchmark, and the panel, service and rewiring an older home often needs are extra. That is not a bill a fixed income covers. It is a reason the renovation does not happen, or happens on the cheap, outside the permit process.

When the power goes out.

Reliability is an affordability issue too. Natural gas delivers with a 99.8 percent reliability rate, including in extreme weather. During a power outage a gas stove still cooks and a gas water heater still heats. For an older resident in a heat wave or a cold snap, that is not a convenience. An all-electric home puts everything on one grid, and PJM’s latest capacity auction cleared 6,831 megawatts short of the region’s reliability requirement.

What AREA is asking for.

Eight in ten homebuyers in the region want to be able to choose gas. For fixed-income households that choice is the difference between a bill they can plan around and one they cannot. Before implementation moves forward, AREA is asking for an impact assessment that counts these households, listening sessions that include them, and a plan for them. Add your name.

TAKE ACTION See what it costs you