All stories

Housing·Research·2 min read

Who carries the cost of a shrinking gas system

Fixed network costs do not fall when customers leave. They are spread across the households who stay.

A woman reads on a tablet at a laundromat counter, a laundry basket and detergent beside her.

Most of what it costs to run a gas system does not depend on how much gas flows through it. The mains under the street, the service lines to each building, the inspections, the leak surveys, the crews on call around the clock: those costs are there whether a neighborhood has a thousand customers or a hundred. Gas bans change the second number without changing the first.

Fewer customers, same pipes.

A utility’s fixed costs are recovered through rates, spread across everyone connected to the system. When new buildings are barred from connecting and renovated buildings are required to disconnect, the pool of customers shrinks over time, but the pipes still have to be maintained and kept safe. The arithmetic is not complicated. The same costs divided among fewer households means a larger share for each one.

Fewer customers. Same fixed costs.

When the number of gas customers falls, the cost of maintaining the system is spread across the households who remain.

Who stays on the system.

The households that leave first are the ones that can afford to. Converting a home to all-electric is a $22,500 to $40,000 project before any electrical upgrades, by the benchmark AREA’s calculator uses. Families with that money, and owners building new, exit the gas system. The people left on it are predictable:

  • Renters, who did not choose their heating system and cannot replace it.
  • Owners of older homes, where conversion costs run highest and electrical service is most likely to need an upgrade.
  • Seniors and fixed-income households, for whom a five-figure conversion is out of reach.
  • Affordable housing, where operating budgets are already thin.

In other words, the households with the least room in their budgets end up carrying the largest share of a system the policy is shrinking around them.

The other side of the switch is not cheaper.

The households that do convert land on a grid with its own cost problem. Residential electricity prices rose 74 percent in DC and 50 percent in Maryland from 2020 to 2025, and electricity is 3.5 times more expensive than natural gas for the same household energy use. PJM, the regional grid operator, ran its latest capacity auction 6,831 megawatts short of the region’s reliability requirement while demand keeps rising. Moving heating, hot water and cooking onto that system adds load and, with it, upward pressure on everyone’s electric bill.

Natural gas, by comparison, delivers with a 99.8 percent reliability rate, including in extreme weather. It is also what keeps hot water and a working stove in the house when the power goes out.

A question the policy has not answered.

Who pays for the gas system as the customer base shrinks, and who pays for the grid as the load grows? Neither the District’s law nor the County’s standard answers it. AREA’s position is that the answer should come before the January 2027 date, not after, and that it should come with a plan for the households most exposed. Join us.

TAKE ACTION See what it costs you